Law, Democracy 
&  Development

Law, Democracy 
&  Development

JOURNAL OF THE FACULTY OF LAW | UNIVERSITY OF THE WESTERN CAPE | ISSN: 2077-4907JOURNAL OF THE FACULTY OF LAW, UWC | ISSN: 2077-4907

>> Volume 5(2) (2001)

  1. Editorial 2001 (2), pp 7-129

    Author/s: Cameron, Edwin

    Read more

  2. Testing for HIV/AIDS: The constitutional standard, pp 213-221

    Author/s: Pillay, Karrisha

    Testing for HIV/AIDS has long been a contentious issue. Karrisha PiIlay examines it in the context of the right of access to health care services embodied in s27 of the Constitution. The author argues that appropriate testing for HIV/AIDS is a key component in an effective strategy for the prevention of HIV/AIDS and thus integral to the right of access to health care services. However, such testing should take place with due regard to the constitutional rights to dignity, equality, freedom and security of the person as well as the right to privacy (where the issue of confidentiality is of particular importance). Pillay then examines the legal framework for HIV testing and concludes that the principles of voluntary testing, confidentiality and pre- and post-test counselling must inform approaches to HIV/AIDS testing.

    Read more

  3. Debunking ‘Conglomo-talk’: A case study of the amicus curiae as an instrument for advocacy, investigation and mobilisation, pp 133-162

    Author/s: Heywood, Mark

    Mark Heywood focuses on the legal action brought by the Pharmaceutical Manufacturers' Association (PMA) to test the constitutionality of an amendment to South Africa's Medicines and Related Substances Control Act of 1965. It traverses some of the history of a case rich in irony, insofar as the PMA utilised rights in the Constitution intended to protect vulnerable people against vested interests. The irony was compounded when the Treatment Action Campaign joined the litigation as amicus curiae to turn the PMA's case against itself. The article concludes with an examination of exactly what was achieved as a result of the case.

    Read more

  4. Taking responsibilities seriously: The role of the state in preventing transmission of HIV from mother to child, pp 163-177

    Author/s: Berger, Jonathan

    Jonathan Berger deals with the issue of the transmission of HIV from mother to child, which is the primary source of infection in young children. The author accepts that preventative interventions substantially reduce mother to child transmission (MTCT) but, without state intervention, access to programmes to prevent MTCT remains an impossibility for most pregnant women in South Africa. The extent to which the Constitution obliges the state to take steps to reduce MTCT is considered, and whether the government is justified in refusing to commit sufficient resources to a MTCT preventive programme in light of factors such as costs and concerns about a high-technology approach to HIV/AlDS. The author concludes that the failure of government to fully implement MTCT preventive programmes is an unjustifiable limitation of the right to make choices concerning reproduction.

    Read more

  5. Aiding intolerance and fear: The nature and extent of AIDS discrimination in South Africa, pp 195-211

    Author/s: Richter, Marlise

    Discrimination on the basis of HIV/AIDS may take different forms. Marlise Richter provides a practice-based exposition of the nature of HIV/AIDS discrimination in South Africa. It has arisen, inter alia, in the areas of employment, insurance, access to education, medical aid, privacy, wilful transmission and the adoption of children. The author goes on to explore the extent to which certain groups are more likely to experience AIDS discrimination. These vulnerable groups, it is argued, may be demarcated along lines of race, gender, sexual orientation, class, education level and economic activity. With reference to a case study it is concluded that the laws presently in place do not go far enough to protect those particularly vulnerable to HIV/AIDS discrimination.

    Read more

  6. FORUM CONTRIBUTION: A summary of some cases on HIV/AIDS, pp 237-241

    Author/s: Rugege, Sam

    Sam Rugege provides concise commentary on two important recent judgments involving discrimination on the basis of HIV/AIDS. The first is a decision by the South African Constitutional Court in Hoffmann v South African Airways [2000] I I BCLR 121 1 (CC) based on the constitutional equality clause. This case raised important issues relating to the extent to which employers can justify discrimination on the basis of the requirements of a job or the perceived prejudices of the public. In addition. novel questions arose in relation to the appropriate remedy for unfair discrimination in cases where an employer has refused to employ applicants on the basis of their HIV status. The second case is a decision of the Namibian Labour Court in N v Minister of Defence (2000) 21 ILJ 999 (NmLC). The applicant in this case was refused employment in the Defence Force because he tested HIV positive. The court found that this constituted unfair discrimination as envisaged by the Namibian Labour Act of 1992 and ordered the applicant's enlistment subject to a medical test.

    Read more

  7. FORUM CONTRIBUTION: Comment on the Code of Good Practice: Key aspects of HIV/AIDS and employment, pp 223-228

    Author/s: Vergnani, Tania and Schaay, Nikki

    Drawing on their experience in drafting an HIV/AIDS workplace policy for the University of the Western Cape, Tania Vergnani and Nikki Schaay reflect on the Code of Good Practice: Key Aspects of HIV/AIDS and Employment in terms of its ability to assist in defining and refining HIV/AIDS policies. They conclude that the Code takes a limited view of workplace responsibility and advocate that employers should play a greater, more pro-active role in the prevention of the spread of the disease and of discrimination, as well as in providing treatment for those living with HIV/AIDS.

    Read more

  8. FORUM CONTRIBUTION: South African court rules on the state’s obligation to prevent mother-to-child transmission of HIV, pp 129-131

    Author/s: Budlender, Geoff

    In Treatment Action Campaign and Others v Minister of Health and Others 2002 (4) BCLR 356 (T) the Pretoria High Court found in favour of the Treatment Action Campaign and others and against the Minister of Health on the issue of mother-to-child HIV transmission. The steps taken by the state in this regard, it was held, were not in compliance with its duty to take reasonable measures to achieve the progressive realisation of the right to access to health care services. On appeal, the Constitutional Court in Minister of Health and Others v Treatment Action Campaign and Others (1) 2002 (10) BCLR 1033 (CC) similarly found that existing state policy fell short of the constitutional standard and ordered the state to devise and implement within its available resources a comprehensive and co-ordinated programme to realise progressively the rights of pregnant women and their newborn children to have access to health services to combat mother-to-child transmission of HIV. Geoff Budlender, who acted as attorney for the applicants in the High Court and subsequently in the Constitutional Court, provides a brief comment on the context and controversies surrounding the justiciability of socio-economic rights.

    Read more

LDD reader guidelines

Law, Democracy & Development (LDD) is an accredited journal - that is, approved by the Department of Education for the publication of subsidised research output. This means that the articles we publish are subject to stringent quality control. All articles, unless otherwise indicated, are peer-reviewed - that is, anonymously assessed by independent experts. In addition, we also publish reviews, commentaries or other contributions which the editors consider topical or important but which have not been subjected to the formal assessment process - for example, contributions by emerging researchers (such as those in our ALAD section), keynote speeches by leading commentators and the like. These non-refereed items are identified as Forum contributions.

LDD is an open-access journal. This means that copyright in all published material remains vested in the author thereof, but the author grants permission for the material to be made available freely on LDD’s website. The material may be quoted, downloaded and/or copied, subject to the following conditions:

  • the name(s), title(s) and institutional affiliation(s) of author(s), as well as a bibliographical reference to its original publication in LDD (author, title of article and volume of LDD) must be included by those who use it; and
  • the copyright of the author(s) – for example, the right to republish or amend the material – remains intact, and articles that are reproduced may not be changed in any way.

Please therefore make full use of the articles contained in LDD for all academic, research or practical purposes – but kindly remember to cite the source so that others can also find it.

Privacy policy

In common with other websites, log files are stored on this website’s web server saving details such as the visitor’s IP address, browser type, referring page and time of visit. Cookies may be used to remember visitor preferences when interacting with the website. Where registration is required, the visitor’s email and a username will be stored on the server. Email addresses will not be sold, rented or leased to third parties. Emails may be sent to inform you of news of our services or offers by us or our affiliates. If you have subscribed to one of our services, you may unsubscribe by following the instructions included in emails that you receive.

Terms of service

All information contained in official UWC websites, and by extension those of the Faculty of Law, is provided for information purposes only and does not represent a legally binding contract between UWC and any person or entity. Information on official university websites is subject to change without prior notice. While every reasonable effort is made to present current and accurate information, UWC, and by extension the Faculty of Law, makes no guarantees of any kind. The LDD site may contain information that is created and managed by various sources, both internal and external to the University. Some online content exists in the form of forums containing the personal opinions and other expressions of the persons who post the entries. UWC promotes freedom of expression and therefore does not control, monitor or guarantee the information contained on these platforms, and does not endorse any views expressed therein. At no time shall UWC, and by extension the Faculty of Law, be responsible or liable, directly or indirectly, for any damage or loss resulting from or alleged to result from the use of or reliance on any such content.

Cookies policy

We use cookies and related technologies on our website. Cookies are small data files that are served by our platform and stored on your device. Our site uses cookies dropped by us or third parties for a variety of purposes including to operate and personalise the website. Our website employs the use the various third-party services. Through the use of our website, these services may place anonymous cookies on the visitor's browser and may send their own cookies to the visitor's cookie file. Some of these services may include, but are not limited to, Google, Facebook, Twitter and other social networks, security firewalls, analytics companies, and service providers. These services may also collect and use anonymous identifiers such as IP Address, HTTP Referrer, Unique Device Identifier and other non-personally identifiable information and server logs.