Law, Democracy
& Development
Law, Democracy
& Development
JOURNAL OF THE FACULTY OF LAW | UNIVERSITY OF THE WESTERN CAPE | ISSN: 2077-4907JOURNAL OF THE FACULTY OF LAW, UWC | ISSN: 2077-4907
Author/s: Sarkin, Jeremy
Author/s: Sarkin, Jeremy
Jeremy Sarkin suggests a possible model for a truth and reconciliation enquiry in Rwanda which was presented to that country's government in 1998. Given the enormous difficulties of prosecuting the estimated 125 000 alleged perpetrators of genocide in Rwanda, he proposes as an interim measure that use be made of existing community-based dispute resolution forums, known as the Gacaca, for local enquiries into the genocide. Traditionally made up of respected older men, the makeup of these structures would have to be carefully considered to achieve a representative body. Communities would have to reach agreement before being able to apply to the government for such a structure to be established. The powers of such bodies and their relationship to the formal justice system would have to be defined. Such a model, however, can only be a first step; a national truth and reconciliation commission, it is argued, is needed to ensure lasting peace in the country.
Author/s: McDonald, Avril
Avril McDonald deals with the possible right of victims to truth, justice and remedies in situations where violations of international humanitarian law constitute crimes under international law. She examines international law on genocide, crimes against humanity and the law on war crimes as well as customary international law. Turning to the duty to prosecute international crimes, McDonald then deals with the different approaches adopted in South Africa, Rwanda and Sierra Leone. She concludes that concerns for the rights of perpetrators and the needs of the country as a whole cannot justify ignoring the needs and rights of victims. In addition to acknowledgement of the wrongs done to victims and various modes of compensation, it is argued, for many victims the need remains to see the perpetrators of the most heinous crimes prosecuted and punished remains.
Author/s: O'Malley, Gabriel
Based on research among victims of human rights violations in South Africa under apartheid, Gabriel O'Malley argues that the Truth and Reconciliation Commission's work is flawed by the lack of recognition for the desire of many victims for revenge. The commission aimed to achieve restorative rather than retributive justice; perpetrators were not required to apologise or to show remorse. The commission's human rights values and Christian ethos required victims to forgive; any expression of anger or demand for revenge was out of place. The author argues that retributive institutions are necessary to remove the psychic burden of vengeance, including a prohibition on high-ranking perpetrators from holding public office and a reparations fund to which perpetrators and beneficiaries may contribute. Perpetrators who did not apply or qualify for amnesty, it is further argued, should be prosecuted.
Author/s: Villa-Vicencio, Charles
Former Truth and Reconciliation Commission research director Charles Villa-Vicencio sees reactions to the work of the commission as falling into three categories: those who rejected the mandate of the commission, those who enthusiastically embraced it. and the majority who are ambivalent. He explores the role of the commission in creating an institutional memory of the past and how difficult it is for many to 'get on with life' once the process is over. In the author's view, it is too soon to tell whether this attempt to heal the wounds of the past has been successful.
Author/s: Fernandez, Lovell
Lovell Fernandez discusses the reparations policy of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission of South Africa. In terms of the founding Act, the commission merely has the power to make recommendations on reparations while Parliament is to decide on it. The commission recommended five forms of reparations: urgent interim reparation, individual reparation grants, symbolic reparation and community rehabilitation, community rehabilitation programmes, and institutional reform. Although some urgent interim reparation payments were made, many applicants are still waiting. No money for individual reparation grants were earmarked in the Budget and no government ministry was given responsibility for implementing the process. No clear reason can be identified why government is failing to meet its obligations to the 22 000 victims identified by the commission.
Author/s: Sarkin, Jeremy
Jeremy Sarkin describes how Ethiopia has chosen to prosecute perpetrators of past human rights violations rather than to use the truth commission route. However, high ranking figures in former regimes have fled to countries where they are immune from prosecution or extradition. Faced with a choice between Ethiopian law or international customary law, the Office of the Special Prosecutor (SPO) decided to use the former because its definition of genocide includes offences against political groups. A second reason is that it was not clear whether it is possible to charge alleged perpetrators with war crimes under international customary law if the alleged crimes were committed in an internal conflict. (This uncertainty has subsequently been resolved.) Various problems with the process are noted, including the fact that it may take up to 20 years to complete . The author argues that it is very difficult to meet the hopes and expectations of victims during war crimes trials. Among other things, victims are seldom involved in such trials; they are denied the catharsis of a truth commission process which focuses on them as victim; and a guilty verdict is far from certain, given the standards of proof demanded in a criminal trial.
Author/s: Tejan-Cole, Abdul
Abdul Tejan-Cole deals with the controversial amnesty provisions of the Lome Peace Agreement in Sierra Leone. While the agreement calls for the establishment of a Truth and Reconciliation Commission, it grants blanket amnesty to all combatants and collaborators against a background of appalling atrocities against civilians, including mass murder. The agreement also gives rebel leaders important positions in the executive. The author argues that this amnesty removes any incentive for perpetrators to participate in the proposed commission's work; in fact, the rebels have been rewarded for what they have done. The amnesty has been widely condemned. Even the United Nations, a guarantor of the agreement, has dissociated itself. The author states that the agreement flouts international human rights and humanitarian law and argues that true and lasting peace and reconciliation cannot be achieved unless the rights of victims are adequately addressed.
LDD reader guidelines
Law, Democracy & Development (LDD) is an accredited journal - that is, approved by the Department of Education for the publication of subsidised research output. This means that the articles we publish are subject to stringent quality control. All articles, unless otherwise indicated, are peer-reviewed - that is, anonymously assessed by independent experts. In addition, we also publish reviews, commentaries or other contributions which the editors consider topical or important but which have not been subjected to the formal assessment process - for example, contributions by emerging researchers (such as those in our ALAD section), keynote speeches by leading commentators and the like. These non-refereed items are identified as Forum contributions.
LDD is an open-access journal. This means that copyright in all published material remains vested in the author thereof, but the author grants permission for the material to be made available freely on LDD’s website. The material may be quoted, downloaded and/or copied, subject to the following conditions:
Please therefore make full use of the articles contained in LDD for all academic, research or practical purposes – but kindly remember to cite the source so that others can also find it.
Privacy policy
In common with other websites, log files are stored on this website’s web server saving details such as the visitor’s IP address, browser type, referring page and time of visit. Cookies may be used to remember visitor preferences when interacting with the website. Where registration is required, the visitor’s email and a username will be stored on the server. Email addresses will not be sold, rented or leased to third parties. Emails may be sent to inform you of news of our services or offers by us or our affiliates. If you have subscribed to one of our services, you may unsubscribe by following the instructions included in emails that you receive.
Terms of service
All information contained in official UWC websites, and by extension those of the Faculty of Law, is provided for information purposes only and does not represent a legally binding contract between UWC and any person or entity. Information on official university websites is subject to change without prior notice. While every reasonable effort is made to present current and accurate information, UWC, and by extension the Faculty of Law, makes no guarantees of any kind. The LDD site may contain information that is created and managed by various sources, both internal and external to the University. Some online content exists in the form of forums containing the personal opinions and other expressions of the persons who post the entries. UWC promotes freedom of expression and therefore does not control, monitor or guarantee the information contained on these platforms, and does not endorse any views expressed therein. At no time shall UWC, and by extension the Faculty of Law, be responsible or liable, directly or indirectly, for any damage or loss resulting from or alleged to result from the use of or reliance on any such content.
Cookies policy
We use cookies and related technologies on our website. Cookies are small data files that are served by our platform and stored on your device. Our site uses cookies dropped by us or third parties for a variety of purposes including to operate and personalise the website. Our website employs the use the various third-party services. Through the use of our website, these services may place anonymous cookies on the visitor's browser and may send their own cookies to the visitor's cookie file. Some of these services may include, but are not limited to, Google, Facebook, Twitter and other social networks, security firewalls, analytics companies, and service providers. These services may also collect and use anonymous identifiers such as IP Address, HTTP Referrer, Unique Device Identifier and other non-personally identifiable information and server logs.