How international human rights law influences domestic law in Africa, pp 378-392
Author/s: Killander, Magnus
International law plays an important role in framing the content of national law. This is evident with regard to norms of environmental law, crime prevention and human rights, to name just a few areas where norms adopted by global and regional organisations influence, and to a certain extent harmonise, national legal and policy frameworks. The focus of this article is on how international human rights law influences the content of national law whether for example through direct application of international human rights law by national courts or through inspiring new national legislation based on international instruments. It also considers the impact of 'international expert' made law, such as, the decisions of regional and UN quasi-judicial bodies and courts. The article provides an overview of these issues in relation to Africa highlighting pertinent examples from national case law and legislation illustrating particular points.
Read more
Guidelines and principles on imprisonment and the prevention of torture under the African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights: How relevant are they for South Africa?, pp 363-377
Author/s: Muntingh, Lukas
It must be regarded as a peculiarity that the African Charter on Human and Peoples' Rights makes no specific mention of prisoners' rights and that these rights have to be inferred from overall reading of the Charter, and in particular articles 4-6. There also does not exist in respect of Africa an instrument such as the UN Standard Minimum Rules for the Treatment of Prisoners or the European Prison Rules, which would operationalise normative law in a manner that is appropriate to the African context. This article assesses the relationship between the African Commission on Human and Peoples' Rights and the South African prison reform debate with reference, first, to the prevention and eradication of torture and other ill-treatment in South Africa and the Robben Island Guidelines, and secondly, to the right to liberty and the recently announced guidelines from the Commission on police and pre-trial detention.
Read more
Seven years in business: Evaluating developments at the African Court on Human and Peoples’ Rights, pp 317-341
Author/s: Nmehielle, Vincent O
This article provides an early evaluation of the work of the African Court on Human and Peoples' Rights in the first seven years of its existence. It interrogates developments at the Court within this period in terms of how the Court has approached its mandate. The article makes clear that the setting up of the Court was not without challenges that related to its effective operationalisation after the Protocol establishing it entered into force. The article finds that the Court's early budgetary situation appears reasonable, presumably due to the current low workload of the Court and it is hoped that it will be sustained as the workload of the Court increases. The article further finds that the low workload could be attributed to the lack of individual access to the Court as a result of the failure of many States parties to deposit the required declaration under the Court's Protocol to allow individuals to bring cases. The article concludes that despite its slow start, the Court has come to stay, after a long and elusive history to establish an effective human rights mechanism that would ensure the protection of the human rights of Africans. In this regard, the Court's recent judgements in the Mtikila and Mkandawire cases against Tanzania and Malawi, respectively, and the very important ruling in the 'Zongo' case against Burkina Faso, clearly demonstrate the potential of the Court.
Read more
Human rights litigation using international human rights law: The IHRDA experience, pp 504-519
Author/s: Theu, Bright
In this rather short article, I share a few experiences of the Institute for Human Rights and Development in Africa (IHRDA) in advancing human rights using the African Charter on Human and Peoples' Rights and related instruments through litigation. By reference to a sampling of cases litigated by, or with the participation of IHRDA before the African Commission on Human and Peoples' Rights, the African Committee of Experts on the Rights and Welfare of the Child, and a few domestic courts, I endeavour to illustrate the practical use of the African Charter on Human and Peoples' Rights and related human rights instruments and mechanisms in advancing human rights in Africa. The article ends by observing that the existence of supra-national mechanisms for redressing human rights violations, commendable as they are, should not generate a euphoria that diverts efforts from strengthening and perfecting domestic jurisdictions which are the primary duty bearers for the vindication of rights.
Read more
From a cat into a lion? An overview of the progress and challenges of the African human rights system at the African Commission’s 25 year mark, pp 298-316
Author/s: Viljoen, Frans
The roots of the African human rights system lie in the African Charter on Human and Peoples' Rights. In many respects, the Charter came about as a compromise between a genuine attempt to curtail state sovereignty in order to enhance rights protection, on the one hand, and efforts to construct a human rights friendly facade to deflect criticism, strengthen international legitimacy and facilitate donor funding, on the other. Some significant developments have taken place over the past 25 years, resulting in an expansion of the norms and institutions making up the African regional system of human rights promotion and protection. At the same time, the African system has been facing and still faces a number of challenges. This article aims to provide a brief overview of some of the most salient advances, over a quarter of a decade, in particular as they relate to individual communications dealt with by the African Commission on Human and Peoples' Rights.
Read more
The right to adequate housing in the African regional human rights system: Convergence or divergence between the African Commission and South African approaches, pp 342-362
Author/s: Chenwi, Lilian
The African Charter on Human and Peoples' Rights makes no mention of the right to housing. Notwithstanding this limitation, the African Commission on Human and Peoples' Rights has creatively, and through applying the principle of interdependence of rights, interpreted other rights in the Charter to include a right to adequate housing plus a right to protection against forced evictions. This article considers the right to adequate housing in the African regional human rights system, with specific emphasis on its enforcement by the African Commission. The discussion of the recognition of the right in the African system and the jurisprudence on it is set against the backdrop of South Africa's approach to the protection and enforcement of this right, with the aim of identifying instances of convergence with or divergence from South Africa's approach.
Read more
The approaches of the African Commission to the right to health under the African Charter, pp 393-418
Author/s: Durojaye, Ebenezer
This article examines the right to health guaranteed under the African Human Rights system and the approaches the African Commission has adopted in interpreting the content of this right. The article starts by examining in detail the provisions of the right to health under international human rights law and then discusses the provisions of the African Charter and African Women's Protocol. It further discusses the various approaches the African Commission has adopted in interpreting these provisions in some of its decisions and their importance in advancing the right to health in the region. The article also examines some of the important non-binding resolutions and General Comments of the African Commission relating to the right to health and their significance in advancing this right in the region. The article concludes by arguing that, while national courts can learn from the approaches adopted by the African Commission in interpreting the right to health guaranteed under the Charter and the African Women's Protocol, the Commission can equally benefit from the decisions of some national courts.
Read more
Litigating socio-economic rights in domestic courts: The Kenyan experience, pp 419-443
Author/s: Arwa, Jotham Okome
The first Kenyan Constitution, which was negotiated at independence, incorporated many of the conventional civil and political rights, but was conspicuously silent on socio-economic rights. This created a situation where very little attention was given to socio-economic rights and culminated in a socio-economic crisis. The socio-economic situation in Kenya has been so dire that it even attracted the attention of the United Nation's Committee on Economic Social and Cultural Rights. In November 2008, at its 41st session, the Committee asked the Kenya government questions on the steps it was taking, inter alia, to address what it perceived as a socio-economic crisis in the country. One of the important steps that the Kenya government took to address the socio-economic problem was the enactment of a new Constitution, the Constitution of Kenya 2010, which entrenched virtually all categories of socio-economic rights. The main challenge, however, has been how to translate the newly introduced socio-economic rights from paper rights to substantive rights. This article examines Kenya's experience in this regard.
Read more
Litigating human rights in South Africa: The experience of the Centre for Applied Legal Studies, pp 444-456
Author/s: Hardy, Kathleen
The Centre for Applied Legal Studies ('CALS') has been involved in litigation aimed at the protection of human rights for more than three decades. CALS has witnessed and experienced the oppressive system of apartheid, worked in South Africa through the transformation into a new democracy, and continues its work in a constitutional democracy. Throughout CALS' experience in litigating human rights, it has used international laws and principles to assist in the recognition and enforcement of human rights. The use of international laws, norms and principles may be in either a direct or an indirect manner. These international laws and principles are incorporated into all aspects of CALS' work, from research through advocacy and litigation. Human rights litigation cannot be separated from international laws and principles.
Read more